Faking a Miscarriage: How Doctors Distinguish Menstruation from Pregnancy Loss
If someone presents to the ER claiming miscarriage but is actually menstruating, clinicians can readily differentiate through history, exam, and testing.
Key Differences
| Feature | Menstruation | Early Miscarriage |
|---|---|---|
| Bleeding | Heavier, bright red, clots common | Lighter, pink/brown, less clotting |
| Cramping | Moderate-severe, cyclical | Mild-moderate, may be one-sided |
| Duration | 3–7 days typical | Variable, often shorter |
| hCG (urine/blood) | Negative | Positive (then declining) |
| Ultrasound | Thickened endometrium, no gestational sac | Empty sac, no fetal pole, or retained products |
| Cervix | Closed, firm, posterior | May be slightly dilated, softened |
| Uterine size | Normal for cycle day | May be enlarged for dates |
