Kidney Transplant Success Rates: What Patients Need to Know

The kidneys are two bean‑shaped organs located beneath the rib cage, one on each side of the spine. Their chief role is to filter waste and excess fluid from the bloodstream, producing urine.

A kidney transplant replaces a diseased kidney with a healthy one from a donor. End‑stage kidney disease (ESKD) is the leading indication for transplantation; without a transplant, patients must rely on long‑term dialysis to survive.

Overall, kidney transplants are highly effective. Approximately 97% of transplanted kidneys function for at least one year, markedly extending patients’ lives.

There are two primary sources of donor kidneys:

Living‑donor kidney transplant (LDKT) – the kidney comes from a living person, often a relative or close friend of the recipient.

Deceased‑donor kidney transplant (DDKT) – the kidney is retrieved from a donor who has passed away.

Read on for a detailed look at the success rates of each approach.

The Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network (OPTN), a nonprofit that oversees the U.S. organ‑sharing system, partners with the Scientific Registry of Transplant Recipients (SRTR) to publish an annual transplant report.

According to the 2020 OPTN/SRTR report, 83.9% of LDKT recipients older than 65 remained alive five years after surgery. The 5‑year survival rate climbs to 97.8% for recipients aged 18‑35. Patients whose kidney failure was caused by diabetes had the lowest 5‑year survival (88.3%).

Five‑year graft survival also favors living donors: 81.6% of kidneys in recipients over 65 and 90.9% in those aged 35‑49 survived at least five years.

While DDKT outcomes are strong, they trail LDKT. In 2020, DDKT procedures were performed roughly four times more often than LDKT, reflecting the larger pool of deceased donors. The 5‑year survival for DDKT was 74.3% in patients over 65 and 95.8% in those aged 18‑34. As with LDKT, diabetes‑related kidney failure reduced the 5‑year survival to 81.1%.

Despite these encouraging numbers, waiting lists remain lengthy. Between 2015 and 2017, of the patients placed on the list:

  • 34.6% were still waiting after three years
  • 25% received a deceased‑donor transplant
  • 14% received a living‑donor transplant
  • 6.4% died while waiting
  • 20% were removed from the list for other reasons

Several factors influence transplant success:

Age

Both donor and recipient ages matter. A 2016 study identified recipient age as the second‑most important predictor of outcomes, noting that older recipients often experience longer graft survival—likely because younger immune systems are more prone to rejection. The same study ranked donor age fourth, with older donors linked to higher rejection rates. OPTN/SRTR data showed organ rejection in 9.1% of recipients aged 18‑34 versus 5.9% of those over 65.

Cold ischemic time

This is the interval between cooling the donated kidney and restoring its blood flow. Shorter cold ischemic times consistently correlate with better surgical success and were the top predictor of outcomes in the 2016 analysis.

Creatinine level at discharge

Post‑operative serum creatinine reflects how well the new kidney is functioning. Higher creatinine at hospital discharge was the third‑most significant outcome predictor in the same study.

Length of hospital stay

Extended hospitalizations were the fifth leading risk factor, signaling more complications and poorer long‑term survival.

Ethnicity

The 2020 OPTN/SRTR report found Asian recipients had the highest graft survival, whereas Black recipients experienced the lowest.

Clinical practice guidelines (2020) recommend that every patient with chronic kidney disease expected to progress to ESKD be evaluated for transplantation, ideally 6‑12 months before dialysis becomes necessary.

Transplant centers may impose additional criteria, such as age limits or restrictions based on comorbidities. The National Kidney Foundation lists common contraindications, including:

  • Recent cancer diagnosis
  • Severe heart disease
  • Insufficient overall health to endure surgery
  • Active infection
  • Tobacco use or substance abuse
  • Obesity

In summary, kidney transplantation offers superior survival compared with dialysis, but donor availability can prolong the wait. Discuss your individual situation with a transplant specialist to determine eligibility and begin the evaluation process.

Kidney Disease - Related Articles