The Midwife's Apprentice: Analyzing the Story's Climax

In Karen Cushman's The Midwife's Apprentice (1995), the climax occurs when the protagonist, Alyce (formerly Brat/Beetle), faces a pivotal test of courage and self-worth.

The Climactic Sequence

After fleeing the midwife Jane Sharp's harsh tutelage and a failed delivery, Alyce works at an inn, believing herself a failure. When a desperate laboring woman, Emma Blunt, is abandoned by the midwife, Alyce initially refuses to help, paralyzed by fear of failure. However, drawing on hard-won knowledge and instinct, she ultimately stays and successfully delivers the baby.

Why This Is the Climax

  • Internal conflict resolved: Alyce confronts her core belief ("I am nothing, I can do nothing") and chooses action over flight.
  • Agency reclaimed: She acts not as an apprentice following orders, but as a midwife making independent decisions.
  • Identity solidified: She accepts the name "Alyce" and her vocation, telling the innkeeper, "I am a midwife's apprentice. I know how to birth babies."

Themes Highlighted

  • Perseverance through failure
  • Self-definition vs. external labels
  • Competence born of experience, not perfection
  • The transformative power of compassion

The subsequent resolution shows Alyce returning to Jane Sharp—not as a subservient apprentice, but as a young woman negotiating her place. The climax is quiet but profound: a girl becoming a person who trusts her own hands.

Infertility - Related Articles