Ethics of Kidney Donation: Prohibition on Financial Incentives

Offering or receiving money for kidney donation is illegal and unethical in virtually all jurisdictions (U.S. NOTA 1984, WHO Guiding Principles). Rationale:

  • Exploitation: Coerces economically vulnerable; undermines informed consent.
  • Commodification: Treats body parts as property; erodes human dignity.
  • Safety: Donors may conceal health risks for payment.
  • Equity: Wealthy recipients bypass waitlist; poor donors bear risks.
  • Trust: Undermines altruistic donation system.

Permitted: Reimbursement of actual expenses (travel, lost wages, medical costs) per strict guidelines. Living donation must be voluntary, informed, and free of coercion. Deceased donation relies on opt-in/opt-out registries.

Kidney Disease - Related Articles