Challenging Paternity Test Results in Georgia: Legal Process and Options

In Georgia, disputing paternity test results involves specific legal procedures. The process depends on whether the test was court-ordered, administrative (child support), or private.

Step-by-Step Process

1. Identify and Document the Error

  • Review the report: chain of custody, lab accreditation (AABB), exclusion/inclusion probability, allele mismatches
  • Common issues: sample mix-up, lab error, alleged father not tested, related alleged fathers not excluded

2. Contact the Testing Laboratory

  • Request full case file, quality control logs, retesting policy
  • Accredited labs have formal complaint and review procedures

3. Legal Context Determines Path

  • Court-ordered test (paternity/legitimation case): File motion for new test under OCGA § 19-7-46. Show good cause (fraud, mistake, new evidence).
  • Administrative (DCSS child support): Request administrative review/hearing; may petition superior court.
  • Private test: No legal standing alone; must initiate court action.

4. File a Motion for New Genetic Testing

  • Must be timely (strict deadlines apply, often 30–60 days from result notice)
  • Allege specific grounds: procedural error, fraud, newly discovered evidence, biological impossibility
  • Court may order retesting at same or different accredited lab

5. Alternative Dispute Resolution

Mediation or arbitration can resolve disputes faster and cheaper, with mutual agreement on retesting.

6. Independent Testing

Private retest at another AABB-accredited lab strengthens your position but doesn't automatically overturn prior legal findings.

Critical Considerations

  • Presumption of paternity: Married husband is presumed father; high burden to rebut.
  • Statutes of limitation: Vary by action type (legitimation, child support, inheritance).
  • Legal representation: Family law attorney essential—procedural errors can forfeit rights.
  • Best interest of child: Courts prioritize stability; late challenges face scrutiny.

Act promptly. Consult a Georgia family law attorney immediately upon discovering potential errors.

Infertility - Related Articles