Diverticulitis Diet: Why Butterfinger Bars Are a Poor Choice & What to Eat Instead

Avoid Butterfinger bars during acute diverticulitis and limit them during remission.

Why They're Problematic

  • High fat (peanut butter, chocolate, palm oil): Delays gastric emptying, stimulates colonic contractions → pain.
  • High sugar/corn syrup: Feeds dysbiotic gut bacteria, promotes inflammation.
  • Low fiber: No benefit for colonic health; displaces fiber-rich foods.
  • FODMAPs: Contains lactose (milk chocolate), fructose (corn syrup), possibly polyols – can trigger IBS-like symptoms overlapping with diverticular disease.
  • Hard, crunchy texture: Risk of traumatizing inflamed diverticula.

Acute Diverticulitis Diet Progression

  1. Clear liquids (1–3 days): Broth, gelatin, juice without pulp, electrolyte drinks.
  2. Low-fiber/low-residue (as tolerated): White rice, pasta, eggs, tender chicken, cooked carrots, canned fruit, white bread.
  3. Gradual reintroduction of fiber: After symptoms resolve, slowly add whole grains, veggies, fruits, legumes (target 25–35 g/day).

Long-Term Prevention Diet

  • High fiber: Whole grains, beans, lentils, vegetables, fruits, nuts, seeds. Old advice to avoid nuts/seeds/popcorn is outdated—studies show no increased risk.
  • Adequate hydration: 2–3 L water/day.
  • Limit red meat, processed meat, refined grains, added sugars.
  • Regular exercise.

Better Snack Alternatives

  • Greek yogurt with berries
  • Apple slices with peanut butter (smooth)
  • Hummus with cooked carrot sticks
  • Small handful of almonds/walnuts
  • Oatmeal with chia seeds

Always follow your gastroenterologist's specific recommendations.

Eating Disorders - Related Articles